1 of 1- laffin
- Member
Offline
I have a question.
Is a colour person really necessary in radio baseball play-by-play? Their repetition of what was just described by the play-by-play man just increases an annoying sound that makes listening to the ball game a chore. The need to fill, what they determine to be dead air, is not necessary. Any pertinent game info has already been detailed and much of what their colour commentary consists of has no bearing on the immediate play. Perhaps if Rogers canned the colour person, they could afford to send Wagner to the road games.
- Chrisphen
- Member
Offline
Re: I have a question.
Baseball is a terrible spectator sport. There should be three colour personalities per game.
- RadioActive
- Moderator
Offline
Re: I have a question.
laffin wrote:
Is a colour person really necessary in radio baseball play-by-play? Their repetition of what was just described by the play-by-play man just increases an annoying sound that makes listening to the ball game a chore. The need to fill, what they determine to be dead air, is not necessary. Any pertinent game info has already been detailed and much of what their colour commentary consists of has no bearing on the immediate play. Perhaps if Rogers canned the colour person, they could afford to send Wagner to the road games.
We've had this discussion before and I have an alternate theory. The "colour man" (or woman, because they've used both) may feel if they don't say anything often enough, they could lose their gig. So by filling every possible spare second on air, they remind their bosses that they're doing their job. Even if it drives people like us crazy.
I could use a lot less of them doing that and talking instead about stuff that's actually relevant rather than analyzing every single pitch and foul-off in a nine-inning game. As the Tremeloes noted in 1967, "Silence Is Golden." (So was Molson, but I'm not sure if they make that kind of beer anymore.)
- Dial Twister
- Member
Offline
Re: I have a question.
Baseball is a terrible spectator sport. There should be three colour personalities per game.
And at least one of them should be playing a banjo.
- RadioAaron
- Member
Offline
Re: I have a question.
Filling dead-air is necessary, as moments of dead-air or near silence don't get picked up by ratings meters.
- Tomas Barlow
- Banned
Offline
Re: I have a question.
A good colour person shouldn't repeat what just happened. They should explain how or why it happened and what is likely to happen next.
- markow202
- Member
Offline
Re: I have a question.
My cousin comes on the weekends to the cottage and sometimes plays the baseball game blaring from his car. Very annoying. I come him Al Bundy.
- mace
- Member
Offline
Re: I have a question.
Is a colour person really necessary in radio baseball play-by-play? Their repetition of what was just described by the play-by-play man just increases an annoying sound that makes listening to the ball game a chore. The need to fill, what they determine to be dead air, is not necessary. Any pertinent game info has already been detailed and much of what their colour commentary consists of has no bearing on the immediate play. Perhaps if Rogers canned the colour person, they could afford to send Wagner to the road games.
We've had this discussion before and I have an alternate theory. The "colour man" (or woman, because they've used both) may feel if they don't say anything often enough, they could lose their gig. So by filling every possible spare second on air, they remind their bosses that they're doing their job. Even if it drives people like us crazy
I could use a lot less of them doing that and talking instead about stuff that's actually relevant rather than analyzing every single pitch and foul-off in a nine-inning game. As the Tremeloes noted in 1967, "Silence Is Golden." (So was Molson, but I'm not sure if they make that kind of beer anymore.)
Golden is no longer produced. I miss their 1970's ads. What's your sign? Female answer: Exit. What's Fred doing at the bottom of the pool? Australian Crawl? Must be. He's down under!!