sowny.net | The Southern Ontario/WNY Radio-TV Forum


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

November 30, 2021 1:44 pm  #1


Should A Newsperson’s Past Jobs Affect Your Trust In Them?

This is a difficult subject, but it’s something I’ve long pondered. A job is a job and you sometimes have to take what you can get, because - as many here know - they're not always easy to get. But can that past position taint you in the future if you wind up working somewhere else?
 
Here are a few examples that illustrate what I mean:
 
John Roberts, FOX News - The former MuchMusic DJ reached the loftiest heights you can in U.S. news, as the White House correspondent for a major network. But if he were to, say, come back to Canada and join CBC or CTV, would his previous post and the network he worked at make it impossible for you to take him seriously? I knew “J.D.” as he was then known when he was working in Canada. He’s a great guy and he was a good news person. Has he forever lost the ability to switch teams simply because of his association with a hard right leaning TV network in the U.S.?

Or if you lean right, would another Canadian like Ali Velshi’s work with a more left-leaning newsroom like NBC make him hard for you to trust?
 
Tony Burman, former Toronto Star columnist - He was a professor at Ryerson’s School of Journalism, a former Toronto Star columnist and once the head of CBC News. But he also served as the head of Al Jazeera’s English network for many years, a station many critics say promotes terror groups and is virulently anti-Israel and anti-Semitic. (For a time, it was also the place where a terrorist video or manifesto seemed to turn up first.)  I always read everything he wrote with a great deal of skepticism because of his past association with them and I could never shake that past job, despite his otherwise impressive credentials.
 
Jennifer Hsiung, CP24 Morning Co-Anchor - Her resume lists a number of impressive accomplishments, ranging from news correspondent, stand-up comic, sports reporter and even event emcee. But she also spent 10 years in Beijing working for both CCTV and CGTN, TV services run and controlled by the Chinese Communist government, which is notorious for using all media for both censorship and propaganda purposes. She was born and raised in Toronto and is back here now working for Bell Media. Does the decade she spent toiling for an admitted arm of the Communist government hurt her credibility as you watch her every morning? Or is that just a job she did and now she has another one?
 
 It’s a dicey question - should you be judged by the places you’ve worked before or is getting a gig just getting a gig, and you can always start again? Frankly, I often find it almost impossible to forget where some of those mentioned above used to be (or in Roberts’ case, still is) - and that affects how I see them now.

Can you look beyond “the way they were” or does that factor into your judgment as you watch or read them now?   

 

November 30, 2021 1:48 pm  #2


Re: Should A Newsperson’s Past Jobs Affect Your Trust In Them?

Yes.

 

December 1, 2021 1:46 pm  #3


Re: Should A Newsperson’s Past Jobs Affect Your Trust In Them?

There is some truth to this...for me personally I used to actually have some respect for guys like Don Martin, Rex Murphy, Robert Fife and Brian Lilley as well as The National Post many years ago....now they're all hard core, right-wing, old white guys yelling at clouds telling me Liberals and Socialism are horrible, conservatives are the way to go, and that Trudeau is an idiot pretty much daily....I mean how much could they have changed?...it must be who they always were?

 

December 1, 2021 1:57 pm  #4


Re: Should A Newsperson’s Past Jobs Affect Your Trust In Them?

Johnny B wrote:

There is some truth to this...for me personally I used to actually have some respect for guys like Don Martin, Rex Murphy, Robert Fife and Brian Lilley as well as The National Post many years ago....now they're all hard core, right-wing, old white guys yelling at clouds telling me Liberals and Socialism are horrible, conservatives are the way to go, and that Trudeau is an idiot pretty much daily....I mean how much could they have changed?...it must be who they always were?

How do you explain Michael Coren, who went the exact opposite way?

     Thread Starter
 

December 1, 2021 4:47 pm  #5


Re: Should A Newsperson’s Past Jobs Affect Your Trust In Them?

RadioActive wrote:

Johnny B wrote:

There is some truth to this...for me personally I used to actually have some respect for guys like Don Martin, Rex Murphy, Robert Fife and Brian Lilley as well as The National Post many years ago....now they're all hard core, right-wing, old white guys yelling at clouds telling me Liberals and Socialism are horrible, conservatives are the way to go, and that Trudeau is an idiot pretty much daily....I mean how much could they have changed?...it must be who they always were?

How do you explain Michael Coren, who went the exact opposite way?

I think he had some kind of an epiphany (perhaps literally?) like Adler did.

 

December 1, 2021 7:05 pm  #6


Re: Should A Newsperson’s Past Jobs Affect Your Trust In Them?

Digging through the entrails of someone's career and holding their past associations against them easily leads to McCarthyism (of the right or the left). I'm not a fan of the Toronto Sun but there are a number of journalists I respect who worked for the paper (or even for the even more discreditiable Sun News Network) at one point or another. Should they be blacklisted? 

I don't know how many people here are old enough to remember Nathan Cohen, one of the most famous theatre critics in the 50s and 60s, until his death in 1971. He worked at various points for the CBC, the Toronto Star, and even the conservative Toronto Telegram. Earlier in his journalism career, however, he worked for the Communist Party's Canadian Tribune and was editor of the English pages of the Vochenblatt, a Communist Yiddish-language publication. 

Similarly, Percy Saltzman, the first face on CBC Television in Toronto and later the first co-host of CTV's Canada AM  - used to work in the Communist Party's print shop in the 1930s. 

Bryan D. Johnson, the Maclean's movie critic, was a Maoist in the 70s. I could name other well known journalists who were Trotskyists, other brands of socialist, or had other views outside the mainstream in their youth, or even more recently. 

I think, generally, it's better to judge people by their current record rather than dredge up their past connections and ancient history. Also, it's important not to judge people based on their current (or past) political views but by their professionalism as journalists or broadcasters. You can privately have compeltely iconoclastic personal views but as long as you conduct your jouralism in an ethical and fair manner, it shoudln't matter. Obviously there are exceptions, but if we were to allow people to be tainted by their past political, personal, or journalistic associations, you'd be left with a much smaller pool of talent, and a far blander pool as well.