sowny.net | The Southern Ontario/WNY Radio-TV Forum


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

July 16, 2024 1:13 pm  #1


CFTO's Noon News Nightmare Was Simply Unbelievable

I'm not writing this to make fun of CTV Toronto's ongoing issues, which have been detailed here all week. But I've worked in television news for 25 years and I have never, ever seen anything like I just did on CFTO's noon news. And I actually feel horrible and commiserate with those who had to sit through this hour behind the scenes. 

It was just incredible. It started with live viz of the torrential rain. At first, it seemed like they were simply covering the storm, which was a huge story in Toronto. But then it went on. And on. And on. For 12 minutes straight, we saw nothing but live shots of two different areas - Nathan Phillips Square and The Lakeshore near Ontario Place. 

The anchors, Michelle Dube and Nathan Downer, ad libbed endlessly about what was on screen, which was the same shot for what seemed like an eternity. They threw to Jessica Smith, with an elongated early weather hit, then went back to the poor duo, who kept on talking about how wet it was. 

It soon became apparent to even non-TV news people that their playback machines were either not working or unavailable and they were going to have to go live as long as that issue lasted. 

Finally, about 15 minutes into the thing, they managed to throw to reporter Natalie Johnson, who was supposed to do a report on a meeting about Toronto traffic congestion at City Hall. But with her story apparently unavailable and the graphic under her constantly changing from "Congestion Crisis" to "Torrential Rain Hits Toronto," she took her live camera on a tour of a soaked City Hall interior, even at one point using her pass to take us into a stairwell and then bizarrely, a washroom on the second floor - all live, with nary a tape in sight.

Finally, after about 3 minutes of prattling on about nothing. she managed to throw to the first actual tape of the newscast - now some 17 minutes into the show! She even referred to her fellow reporter Beth McDonnell, who had a story about a government official, but was forced to quote him instead of showing what he actually said. More ad lib filler followed, as everyone involved was obviously told to S-T-R-E-T-C-H. And stretch they did. 

Next, McDonnell finally came on and had the longest intro to a piece in TV history, before her story miraculously played. 

After that, there was a time filling Q&A with Scott Hirst about the Republican Convention. Still no real tape or clips. 

When Jessica Smith's weather came on after a spot break, it was around 12:36, with only three actual stories covered. She motor mouthed on endlessly, as well, trying to stretch out the segment. 

It got a bit better after the break, but it was obvious whatever happened had killed the entire show. As I said, I'm not laughing. That must have been torture for the crew and I'm sure 1 PM could not have come fast enough. Except for some reason, they stayed on until 1:06, before the thing mercifully ended for good. Oh to be a fly on the wall in that control room and studio when the credits rolled!

And one more sidebar to Ms. Smith: please, please, please stop telling viewers that when the big storm is over it will be "like it never happened." She says this after every rain event. Tell the people whose cars were flooded out that it "never happened." Say that to the people who are dealing with flooded basements. And tell those who couldn't get to their subway stations filled with water or who got soaked by the deluge and had to work in drenched clothing. 

She does this a lot. And believe me, it DID happen. 

Anyway, I hope CFTO cures whatever was plaguing it on Tuesday afternoon. Otherwise, I might recommend cancelling the 6. Because no one deserves to go through that again.

Aren't there two Big Bang Theory episodes you can sub?

 

July 16, 2024 8:31 pm  #2


Re: CFTO's Noon News Nightmare Was Simply Unbelievable

Outside of a live hit glitch that went dead, the CFTO 6 was almost perfect. Whatever plagued the noon was fixed. But what a mess!

     Thread Starter
 

July 17, 2024 1:51 pm  #3


Re: CFTO's Noon News Nightmare Was Simply Unbelievable

I watched the first 15 minutes of yesterday's 12noon CTV Toronto cast on CP24.  It wasn't as bad as RA is saying.  I thought everyone on air did a decent job padding and covering for whatever technical issues they were having. They had more of just the two shots of the flooding and would show the live weather map from time to time, and the two anchors. Yesterday's noon hour flood and storm certainly warranted the 12 or 13 minutes of coverage off the top.  The on air staff generally did a good job for the viewer given the circumstances they seemed to be having.  Anyone who has been on air live and suddenly told to stretch out a break or segment knows how hard this can be, especially when you don't have all the details or information.     

 

July 17, 2024 3:04 pm  #4


Re: CFTO's Noon News Nightmare Was Simply Unbelievable

You didn't see the entire show, where it just got worse and worse. But yes, the opening part was where it became most painful. 

You certainly have the right to your opinion and that's fair. But I've done local TV news shows where nearly everything has gone wrong and trust me, every minute feels like an hour. You come out of that control room feeling like you've had blood drained from your arm for 60 minutes straight.

And it wasn't just me. I actually had a former and very talented newsroom colleague phone me in the middle of the show to ask, "what the hell is going on at CFTO? Are you watching the noon?" And then we spent several minutes on the line gaping at the screen, astounded at how badly it went off the rails. "Seventeen minutes with no tape?" he observed, astonishment in his voice. He's been through the wars enough to know how impossible that is. 

I can't speak for CTV Toronto, but as soon as you get back to the newsroom, the post mortem begins to try to figure out what happened and why. Sometimes fingers get pointed in the wrong direction. 

So yes, I was harsh about what went out on that screen Tuesday. I've never seen anything quite like it. But if it wasn't entirely clear in my original critique, those on air acquitted themselves amazingly well considering the circumstances. I congratulate them. It isn't easy to tap dance for over an hour like that when everything in the background is falling apart. 

Been there, done that. 

I'm glad they fixed whatever went wacko yesterday. But while it was never quite that bad, this stuff has been happening on the station's newscast for weeks. And you have to wonder when it's going to stop and what's behind it. Whatever it is, it needs to end right away if they want to keep claiming, as they do in their animated opening intro, that they're Toronto's #1 newscast. 

For the past little while, they sure haven't looked like it.

     Thread Starter
 

July 17, 2024 3:28 pm  #5


Re: CFTO's Noon News Nightmare Was Simply Unbelievable

I agree that CFTO's news isn't the appointment newscasts they use to be and I am sure they aren't as dominate in the ratings like they once were.  Bell doesn't carry CFTO here in Kitchener other than being an option, so if I want to watch their 6pm or late night newscasts, it is on CP24. 

I am guessing but probably much of whatever the issue was yesterday at noon could have been weather related.   After 11am was when the rain was at it's peak in many parts of Toronto.  Maybe somewhere along the chain there was a power outage.  I thought the reporter showing all of the flooding and leaking at city hall was interesting.  Looks like the Science Centre isn't the only building in need of repairs. 

Also my point of view was more from a viewers perspective and not so much from the crew and those behind the scenes who likely were pulling their hair out.  At least the problems didn't really show up that much on air from what I viewed.  For the crew and technical people, that must have been another story.