Offline
On Thursday, the CRTC finally seems to have sealed the fate of the troubled CKFG-FM, aka G98.7, after the death of its founder Fitzroy Gordon. The Commission found the place to be continually in non-compliance with a host of regulations and received a large petition demanding that the station be sold to Black owners.
In the end, the CRTC decided not to follow that advice and now the same guy who owns the ethnic outlet (but mostly India-based) CINA-AM Mississauga is in control. The decision shows just how much politics played a role in the decision.
"The Commission understands the concerns raised by numerous members of the Caribbean and African communities and in particular that the station should remain Black-owned and operated. However, no bids were received by a member of this community as part of the court-supervised sale and investment solicitation process, nor did any specific party intervene in this proceeding to express interest in purchasing the station.
"Accordingly, the Commission has imposed safeguards to ensure that approval of the transaction will yield important and real benefits to the community the station is required to serve, particularly with respect to the reflection of the Caribbean and African communities of Toronto in the programming of the station and prominent involvement of members of these communities in the operation of the station."
I can't quite remember reading anything like that in a previous CRTC decision. But it goes further. The petition had almost 15,000 signatures demanding a Black owner, using this provocative language in the submission.
"...it is the very definition of Institutional/Systemic Racism to have anyone outside of the Black Community to own the Black voice.”
There were some members of that community that wanted to try for the licence but when they discovered the purchase price, which ultimately came to an eye-opening $6,250,574, they dropped out. But the despite their worries, the CRTC has mandated that the station retain its format and continue to serve the Black population.
One other interesting note - an intervenor - CIRV-FM, an ethnic station at 88.9 in Toronto - noting the new owner has experience with non-English radio, tried to insert a licence clause that would prohibit G98.7 from airing programming in other languages. The CRTC didn't see it as a problem and will allow the station to broadcast up to 15% of its airtime in third-language programming if it chooses.
Despite having a new owner, the Commission wants CKFG to get back in compliance and has only given it a short-term licence renewal to ensure it follows the rules. All in all, one of the more interesting and unusual CRTC decisions I've read in a while.
Offline
So it is racist to have a Non-Black to own the Black Voice. That sounds like the Jane/Finch crowd talking. Are there no wealthy Black Canadians in the GTA? I am sure there are many. Perhaps they are not interested in owning a radio station, since no offers to purchase CKFG were received from the Black Community. The station will continue to air programming of interest to African/Caribbean Canadians. Problem solved!
Offline
And what time does the Indian music and brokered programming begin?
Over the past few years, there were a number of people, including employees who were interested in buying the station (I spoke to/met with several) - but no-one had anywhere near the amount of money that the receiver in bankruptcy was seeking. The problem at the end of the day, is the fact that the station is non-viable. There is a relatively poor signal in Scarborough, where a significant %age of the audience lives. High operating costs (the FCP transmitter site (likely) costs more than $150,000 per year), and the revenue base was for the station, was never that great. Too much reliance on small businesses who don't always pay their bills on time. Not enough agency/national business to sustain the station. All of that before the pandemic and widespread streaming of music by the target audience. At a $6M (plus CRTC tangible benefits) entry cost, only a profitable broadcaster, who has synergies such as existing studios, technical, accounting etc., might make a go of it. I'm not saying that there weren't a a number of people who could have come together to invest - but big banks don't normally fund people who wish to invest in highly leveraged businesses these days, that were already insolvent.
Turning to Mr. Ray.... With nearly 19 hours of "prime" real estate available for brokered S. Asian programming, (15% of hours 6 am to midnight) Neeti Ray can probably recoup some of his operating costs. He should be able to get several hundred dollars per hour from S. Asian radio program brokers. And over night he's not regulated, so he can sell off another 42 hours a week of brokered ethnic programming. That's not going to make him rich, but I could see a scenario where he comes back to the CRTC in a few years seeking to move the needle up to 40% ethnic, because of declining or lack of revenues from the core "black" programming.
Just sayin'
BTW, do you know how many ads you've got to sell at literally "a dollar a holler" to pay for the rental and power on that FCP transmitter??? A lot!
I've known a lot of "rich" people who invested in failing radio operations, either by way of competitive licence sweepstakes or buying existing operations. Most of them learn the hard way that broadcasting is not a philanthropic past time. Most wealthy people who I know, want to see a reasonable rate of return on their money. There are exceptions. A few "rich" people I've known have bought failing A.M. stations "low" and sold off the land to developers for tens of millions. It literally did not matter if the stations "made money". They could afford to keep running the stations for years. Those folks co-sited with other stations and pocketed millions after the cositing costs, and paying tax on the land sales. But those are exceptional stories. The day of the "one station" rich entrepreneur who makes a fortune owning a single radio station are probably over. There are few if any "Harvey Glatt" opportunities out there for a wealthy investor to own a station and make a great return on his/her investment.
Sadly owning a radio station to serve the black community isn't going to make much money. Perhaps the exception was Milestone (Denham Jolly) whose core money-making businesses I recall were either retirement homes, or nursing homes. I also believe he had some media experience as the publisher or owner of Contrast Magazine. Not sure the radio station CFXJ 93.5 made much money, but at a sale price of $27M, Milestone didn't do too badly when they sold the station CTV Limited in 2010. But those were in the "halcyon" days, when radio stations sold for multiples that were many times their EBITDA.
Last edited by tvguy (August 13, 2021 10:32 am)
Offline
mace wrote:
That sounds like the Jane/Finch crowd talking. Are there no wealthy Black Canadians in the GTA? I am sure there are many.
Michael Lee-Chin for one could have bought it with his pocket change, but obviously knows a bad deal when he sees it.