Why Are So Many Radio Spots So Bad Right Now?

Skip to: New Posts  Last Post
Posted by RadioActive
September 22, 2024 1:32 pm
#1

I have to admit I was never a fan of commercials, but I do understand they're a necessary evil to keep a station going. 

Maybe it's the halo of yesterday's haze, but it seems to me the spots running on radio these days are among the worst ever. And the repetition factor makes them even more unbearable. It just seems there have never been so many unlistenable pitches coming into your ear as there have been in the last year or two.

Gone are the jingles that at least made them memorable and tolerable, like "Things go better with Coke" or "H-O-N-E-ST-E-D, Honest Ed, Crazy Honest Ed." 

They've been replaced with Spence Diamonds, one of the biggest culprits as they take over everything but commercial free CBC Radio 1. But they're not alone. Those awful, awful Subway come-ons for their new snack product are like an earache for the brain. And I still have no idea what a ciabatta bun is, nor do I ever care to find out.

Then there's Frank Leo, Food Basics, 1-800-GOT-JUNK, those awful 'super powered' idiocy claims from Alpine Credits, the new horrendous Sleep Country come-ons - and please don't get me started on the live hits from Tom's Place. The fact that they repeat over and over and over on a daily basis just makes it worse. Not to mention segueing into five minutes of them in a row, which is almost guaranteed to make you flee to another station if you're in the car. 

I get that they pay for programming but how does putting on 8-10 unlistenable ads in a row encourage hours tuned?

Is it my imagination or is this the worst time in radio history for terrible commercials? How can there be so many with so little quality? Paging Terry O'Reilly: what happened to the spots that used to be at least tolerable? These are definitely not the pause that refreshes. 

 
Posted by newsguy1
September 22, 2024 3:51 pm
#2

I have mentioned the ad on the board before but it is worth pointing out again since it is now featured in almost every commercial break on major stations.
It's the Bel Air direct insurance ad where an announcer says "sneaking out shouldn't be easy."Then we heart a man's voice say, "is that you kiddo?"
Then a little boy's voice asnwers, no dad you are just dreaming, go back to sleep."
Huh?  if someone is dreaming they are asleep.
Then the father says "Nice try, go back to your room."
OK, so apparently the father catches his very young son trying to sneak out of the house in the middle of the night.
And he find it amusing.
The kid sounds like he's 10 years old.
WTF is going on here?
The point of the ad is that getting Bel Air insurance is easy.
Still, what has getting insurance got to do with a little boy trying to sneak out in the middle of the night?
Not to mention the nonsensical script.
The other ad that perplexes me is the one where an announcer tells an employee not to sound so excited about their product and suggests the man tone things down.
What? so an employee is supposed to sound unexcited about the product he's selling?
When the man is sufficiently calm about the product, the announcer says, approvingly, "nailed it."
And, of course, why on earth is it necessary for that deep gravelly voiced announcer to bellow deafeningly about the "Wowza products" at Food Basics.
Have you ever heard a person use the term wowza in real life?
let alone feel the need to bellow and scream about the products?
I could go on, and RA has already mentioned many more intolerable ads, including the latest utterly bizarre offering from Spence in which Fiona has come back from a tour of diamond producing countries, like Angola and Botswana, both of which have suffered years of bloody violence and wars. "Lovely people!"

Last edited by newsguy1 (September 22, 2024 3:52 pm)

 
Posted by RadioActive
September 22, 2024 4:22 pm
#3

Which is not to say there aren't a few good ones hanging around. I kind of like the "Two Men & A Truck" commercials that get played on the Jays' broadcast. A great little jingle with easy to remember lyrics and very catchy. And I never get tired of it when it comes on. So it can be done. It's just that all too often it isn't. 

 
Posted by AspectRatio
September 22, 2024 4:39 pm
#4

RadioActive wrote:

and please don't get me started on the live hits from Tom's Place

Those are awful. It's been pointed out here before that at least he's supporting local radio, and that's indeed something - but the trade-off with that is putting a non-broadcast professional on the airwaves to ramble on for what feels like an hour at a time. (Not sure how long it is in actuality? 2 minutes? 3 minutes?)    Talking about his gym club workouts. Talking about his last physicals. Talking about the galas he's attended. Zero of that interests me.

Worse is when he opts to break into song and the man simply can't carry a tune - painful.

And even worse, over the last few weeks poor Tom has seemed to have developed quite the stutter beginning his segments. There's always a "G-g-g-good morning, John" for the 1010 throws. Whether nerves or being on the line too long with anticipation, I don't think he has the self-awareness to listen to his spots or have a speech therapist coach him on some enunciation or nerve-calming habits. Just terrible.

I actually think I'd take those repetitive, produced commercials all day in 30-second bites than the rambling Tom, but it's definitely a tough call.

 
Posted by Chrisphen
September 22, 2024 4:57 pm
#5

Just wait until AI starts writing the copy for Spence.

 
Posted by newsguy1
September 22, 2024 6:18 pm
#6

I give Tom a break because I think he's done a great job building such a quality clothing shop and tailoring business.
I don't believe he has much more formal education than grade 10 and has really made himself into a successful man.
He knows clothing.  He's not an intellectual.
 

 
Posted by RadioActive
September 22, 2024 8:22 pm
#7

newsguy1 wrote:

I give Tom a break because I think he's done a great job building such a quality clothing shop and tailoring business.
I don't believe he has much more formal education than grade 10 and has really made himself into a successful man.
He knows clothing.  He's not an intellectual.
 

Maybe, but his spots are so bad, I find them unlistenable. They're one the of the few things that - if my radio is in another room - I'll actually get up and race to the dial to tune him out. Can't say that for many other campaigns, even the ones I dislike. At least I know when they're scheduled. 

 
Posted by turkeytop
September 22, 2024 9:24 pm
#8

At night, I listen to a lot of American radio. They're full of ads for getting out of paying your debts, lowering your golf score and losing weight with a magic pill.

Some ads are so annoying that I just have to shut the radio off until I think they might be over. Kars 4 Kids, California Psychics, Better Help, Medi-share.


After all is said and done, more is usually said than done.
 
Posted by Shorty Wave
September 23, 2024 8:51 am
#9

Chrisphen wrote:

Just wait until AI starts writing the copy for Spence.

 
Good point. I just heard the new Spence spot talking about De Beers being sold and Sarah loving Michael, I think. It felt all over the place and I wondered why, maybe AI copy, or maybe just a terrible ongoing concept.

 
Posted by Doug Thompson
September 23, 2024 10:08 am
#10

During my almost 60 year career in broadcasting, I've worked with a few writers who treated the listener with respect and wrote amazing radio commercials. Bill McDonald was the first. we met at CHUM when I was Production Manager. Bill and I were partners in a creative company for several years before Chuck Blore beckoned him to Los Angeles and superstardom. Bill also wrote the CHUM documentaries The Story of The Beatles, The Elvis Presley Story and The Evolution of Rock. Then there's Terry O'Reilly, formerly of Pirate Radio & Television (in the Canadian Advertising Hall of Fame). Larry MacInnis (Al Paladini) and Mike Occomore. I'm sure there are a lot more out there who really care about what they write, but these are 4 I've loved working with. Bill, Terry, Larry and Mike are writers who care very much that advertising doesn't 'suck'.  Ad agencies usually give radio to their junior writers and sadly, radio stations aren't paying writers very well today. And as the old saying goes, '"you get what you pay for".

Last edited by Doug Thompson (September 23, 2024 10:09 am)

 
Posted by Binson Echorec
September 23, 2024 10:33 am
#11

Doug Thompson wrote:

Ad agencies usually give radio to their junior writers and sadly, radio stations aren't paying writers very well today.

Also, most of today's writers aren't writing specifically for radio, even if they know what radio "is". I've heard some radio spots that use the audio ripped from the television version and consequently, sound terrible.

I hate to admit it but it's true; radio is an afterthought these days.

 
Posted by newsguy1
September 23, 2024 11:24 am
#12

The last really good radio ads to me were the earlier Alpine Credits.
They got a bit stale toward the end but the earlier ones were really funny and well, voiced.
I don't think there is anything like them right now, and of course the new ones are mediocre and unimaginative.  How many times have you heard an ad where the pitch is that they are "superheroes."  Yawn.

 

Last edited by newsguy1 (September 23, 2024 11:25 am)

 
Posted by Walter
September 24, 2024 5:11 pm
#13

According to the latest moronic Spence ads, 'The world is lucky to have Fiona'. 

 
Posted by RadioActive
September 24, 2024 5:29 pm
#14

You'll soon have to not only hear those 1-800-GOT JUNK ads, you'll have to listen to the guy who started the company. 

New Dragon Brian Scudamore doesn't think you need a degree to become a successful entrepreneur

 
Posted by Chrisphen
September 24, 2024 5:59 pm
#15

RadioActive wrote:

You'll soon have to not only hear those 1-800-GOT JUNK ads, you'll have to listen to the guy who started the company. 

New Dragon Brian Scudamore doesn't think you need a degree to become a successful entrepreneur

In fairness, business education is mostly skills training and doesn't merit existence at a degree-granting level. 

 
Posted by betaylored
September 25, 2024 7:21 pm
#16

I'd like to add to the dishonorable mention category: the ad where the woman is super stressed out about finding four dollars to get some deal at McDonald's?

And I do not like the LOV, Lexus of Vaughan spots, the world does not need another acronym, acronyms are a LSMFT as my dad used to say when aggravated.

Last edited by betaylored (September 25, 2024 7:25 pm)

 
Posted by newsguy1
September 25, 2024 8:03 pm
#17

I believe the finding the four dollars on the pavement ad is for Subway sandwiches.
Subway has never recovered from when its pitchman Jarrod was convicted of being a CHOMO (sorry about the acronym).
After that Subway kept getting called out for its inferior food quality (former employees telling tales like how gross the tuna is.)
There were also stories on social media from former employees talking about getting fired for putting too much toppings on the sandwiches.(in other words giving a good deal).
By the way, though I have not heard any Taco Bell ads lately I went to Taco Bell last week after it opened a new store near me.
I had not tried TB for years and thought, why not give it a try.
I remembered it as being pretty OK, but not exactly gourmet Tax Mex food.
My god the beef burrito supreme I ordered was nigh on uneatable.
Absolutely disgusting.
I was afraid I would be sick within hours after eating it.



 

 


 
Main page
Login
Desktop format