sowny.net | The Southern Ontario/WNY Radio-TV Forum


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

July 23, 2015 11:56 am  #1


CRTC To Broadcasters: There'll Be A Price To Pay For Simsub Errors

The CRTC announced on Thursday that it's about to go looking into a sore spot with me - simultaneous substitution. I understand that it helps keeps local stations alive, but it's always annoyed me. The commission isn't willing to get rid of it, of course (with the exception of the Super Bowl in 2017, a decision that's under a legal challenge from both Bell and the NFL.)

Now, though, they're asking for comments on their new policy - namely, making stations or networks pay the price if they screw up the rejoin to a program you're watching. According to the CRTC, if a local station makes a simsub error and interrupts programming because of it, they may be denied the ability to substitute their own spots in a given program genre for a period of time as a penalty.

Distributors of programming would potentially have to pay a fine to customers incovenienced by the error, although how that would work is still a mystery. (Perhaps money off your monthly bill, which would give viewers an incentive to grouse about every little slip.) Either way, both local stations and cable/sat companies won't be happy about this.  

I'd rather they get rid of it altogether and let us choose which channel we want to watch a show on, but I can't help but wonder if the public really gloms on to this, how many complaints the CRTC will actually get - and how much it will cost broadcasters. I see these mistakes all the time, despite Bell's insistence that it doesn't happen often and they get very few viewer reactions when it does.  

This one isn't as prominent as 'pick and pay' but it could be an interesting issue for those who don't come back in time during a live event like the Oscars or a regular season NFL game. 

We now join the CRTC's ruling, already in progress...

The price for simsub errors

Call for comments on simsub

 

July 23, 2015 12:21 pm  #2


Re: CRTC To Broadcasters: There'll Be A Price To Pay For Simsub Errors

Just be thankful you don't have to deal with U.S. syndex rules where they would just black out the station that isn't in the local viewing area.  Wouldn't that make for a pleasant surprise when you come home to watch the show you thought you PVRd.

But I do agree that there's nothing more annoying than sloppy simsub but the problem is that it's the BDU that does the work, not the broadcaster.  Fining them for infractions is really the only answer.

As an aside, I've been doing some work lately with a large multi-national resturant chain that advertises in both U.S. and Canada.  One of the biggest issues the Canadian operation has is dealing with people who can't get the item they saw advertised on TV -- from an American ad.  It amazes me how many people don't really twig to the difference.  They just blindly watch what's in front of them.  But I digress. 

 

 

July 23, 2015 1:25 pm  #3


Re: CRTC To Broadcasters: There'll Be A Price To Pay For Simsub Errors

RadioActive wrote:

I'd rather they get rid of it altogether and let us choose which channel we want to watch a show on, but I can't help but wonder if the public really gloms on to this,

I can honestly understand where the Canadian broadcasters are coming from.  If they pay the Canadian rights for a program broadcast in this country, then they deserve to control the Canadian eyes that can see it.    The prime time stuff isn't cheap, and if you must water down your audience because in Toronto someone might watch the show on CTV while others can watch the same show on CBS, but with US Spots, then to be honest, why bother.

There needs to be some type of firewall in place to protect the broadcaster.  Option 2 would be like they used to do with the local sports teams, and just run a screen on CBS saying it's blacked out, and for content go to CTV.  That would drive people insane.  I think the current solution is much better.

Would you pay a fee to provide a service, if you knew the store next door was giving away the same product for free?  You wouldn't stay in business long if the answer is yes.



 


Madness takes its toll.  Please have exact change.
 
 

July 23, 2015 3:05 pm  #4


Re: CRTC To Broadcasters: There'll Be A Price To Pay For Simsub Errors

ig wrote:

I can honestly understand where the Canadian broadcasters are coming from.  If they pay the Canadian rights for a program broadcast in this country, then they deserve to control the Canadian eyes that can see it.    The prime time stuff isn't cheap, and if you must water down your audience because in Toronto someone might watch the show on CTV while others can watch the same show on CBS, but with US Spots, then to be honest, why bother.

There needs to be some type of firewall in place to protect the broadcaster.

As someone who made a pretty good living (if you call that "living!") in the industry, I see simsub's value. But in my other role as average viewer, it drives me insane. Still, it's not as bad as it used to be, when Canadian stations were allowed to show more commercials in an hour than they are now (or maybe it was the States that changed.) I can't tell you how well I remember watching a show and seeing the blatant editing, done with all the subtlety of the Texas Chainsaw Massacre, absolutely destroying American shows seen on Great White North outlets, all to get in a few more spots. I guess that's never left me and why I still hate it so much.

The other thing simsub has done is forced almost all Canadian networks to show the same show at the same time as their Uncle Sam counterparts, in order to get the simsub benefit. If that practice was removed, Canadian broadcasters would have much more freedom to arrange their schedules, without having to be slavishly following what happens in boardrooms in New York or L.A.

Those of us old enough can recall when local stations here would pre-release American shows, sometimes a day or two earlier or with even half an hour or so difference. In those pre-VCR/DVR days, it meant you didn't have to choose between two favourites shows on at the same time. Technology has obviated that problem, of course, but it's another consequence of simsub that Canadian operators no longer completely control their own schedules.  

Still, folks like me do have one solution. There's no substitution for an old fashioned Over The Air TV antenna, simultaneous or not. Problem solved and no cable/sat fees going to Rogers or Bell as a big bonus.   

Last edited by RadioActive (July 23, 2015 3:07 pm)

     Thread Starter
 

July 23, 2015 3:15 pm  #5


Re: CRTC To Broadcasters: There'll Be A Price To Pay For Simsub Errors

RadioActive wrote:

 Still, folks like me do have one solution. There's no substitution for an old fashioned Over The Air TV antenna, simultaneous or not. Problem solved and no cable/sat fees going to Rogers or Bell as a big bonus.   

Isn't that a dangerous place to stand though?  What happens if you move a bit further north where you have no access to the border stations, and now, relying on off-air, and understanding that Canadian stations aren't picking up the US shows because they can't get value for their money, you end up watching "Numismatics Unlimited" because the local CBC outlet can't get anything better.

The catch is obviously that the BDU would continue to reap the benefits since you can watch via satellite, but the local broadcast outlet should just shrug and give up.

It's easy to say you'll take option 2 when there's more than one option.  
 


Madness takes its toll.  Please have exact change.
 
 

July 23, 2015 3:35 pm  #6


Re: CRTC To Broadcasters: There'll Be A Price To Pay For Simsub Errors

ig wrote:

RadioActive wrote:

 Still, folks like me do have one solution. There's no substitution for an old fashioned Over The Air TV antenna, simultaneous or not. Problem solved and no cable/sat fees going to Rogers or Bell as a big bonus.   

Isn't that a dangerous place to stand though?  What happens if you move a bit further north where you have no access to the border stations, and now, relying on off-air, and understanding that Canadian stations aren't picking up the US shows because they can't get value for their money, you end up watching "Numismatics Unlimited" because the local CBC outlet can't get anything better.

The catch is obviously that the BDU would continue to reap the benefits since you can watch via satellite, but the local broadcast outlet should just shrug and give up.

It's easy to say you'll take option 2 when there's more than one option.  
 

In my case, I have no need and plans to move farther north, so I suppose I don't have to worry about it, as long as OTA exists in the States. But I admit I do feel sorry for those who can't get the border signals off air. Although with so much available online and so many going there, along with DVR and its skippable commercial capability, the truth is, simsub will begin to matter a lot less as we head towards the future. That may not be good for Canuck broadcasters, but it is a fact of life they'll have to get used to and learn to cope with - or else, sadly, cease to exist.  

     Thread Starter