An "Old" Newsroom Dilemma: When Can Someone Be Called "Elderly?"

Skip to: New Posts  Last Post
Posted by RadioActive
May 30, 2025 10:13 am
#1

The terrible story of the Pickering woman allegedly stabbed to death by a 13-year-old reminded me of something that used to be a hot topic in one of the newsrooms where I worked. How old does someone have to be before you can reasonably call them "elderly?" 

Back in the days before the Internet and social media - aka the quiet old days - viewers used to call up and complain if we did a story on an accident and call the victim "elderly," especially if they were in their mid-late 60s. A lot of the writers were younger (and so was I!) and considered people of a certain age to be worthy of that term. 

The complaints started a big discussion about when that word could reasonably be used to describe someone. I'm not sure if we ever decided on an actual number, but it might have been a person in their 70s or older. But a viewer would always gripe, insisting they didn't consider themselves "elderly."

Durham Police have not given an age for the victim in Thursday's terrible murder, except using the "e" word. 

My advice was to just leave the potentially offensive term out of a story if you didn't know the age. 

As I recall, we never did come to a full agreement on this. Some producers kept using it, others dropped it unless they knew the age for certain. And even then it was a judgement call,

What would you do if confronted by this? 

 
Posted by Binson Echorec
May 30, 2025 10:37 am
#2

What's wrong with using "senior"?

 
Posted by RadioActive
May 30, 2025 10:48 am
#3

I think "senior" wasn't a problem, especially when someone is over the relatively accepted legal definition of 65 or older.

It was the "elderly" word that upset some viewers, who admitted their age, but insisted that didn't make them "elderly," which kind of implies infirm and perhaps not vigorous. 

 
Posted by paterson1
May 30, 2025 11:37 am
#4

One report said the woman was in her 80's.  Wouldn't that be elderly?

 
Posted by RadioActive
May 30, 2025 11:45 am
#5

I have not confirmed an age, but that would certainly be fair if she was that old.

The dilemma in my old newsroom was writers who were still quite young using the "E" word for people as young as 55 or so.

Some viewers in that age group took great offense to that and let us know - in those days, by phone. 

Of course, that was also when you actually had someone answering calls in a newsroom. Today, you'd likely just get voicemail or never get through at all. 

 
Posted by Binson Echorec
May 30, 2025 11:53 am
#6

Maybe "elderly" is/was being used relatively? 55 is elderly to me if I'm 31 or under. If I'm 46, maybe not so much.

As stated, "senior" seems to have been hard coded into us to kick in at 65 and seems to ruffle fewer feathers.

Last edited by Binson Echorec (May 30, 2025 11:53 am)

 
Posted by RadioActive
May 30, 2025 12:25 pm
#7

Worth noting that the story has changed slightly - they're now saying the accused is 14 and not 13 as originally reported.

 
Posted by newsguy1
May 30, 2025 12:32 pm
#8

I have been faced with this issue, and the solution was (is) simple.
Just don't use any adjective to describe people in a way that pigeon holes them.
Just write, an 82 year old man was stabbed by a 20 year old man.
Let the listener describe them to themselves, but don't you as a news reporter do it for them.
I long ago stopped referring to people as a "grandmother or grandfather."
I also noticed that news writers would often describe a woman as a grandmother if she was say, 62 years old, but rarely would a writer automatically describe a 70 year old man as a grandfather unless the story specifically was about the man being a grandfather.
Women also get described by their status as a mother or grandfather when it is irrelevant to the story.
For instance in a crime story a man might be described as a 48 year old man, whereas a woman would be described as a 55 year old mother of three.
The story is about the crime they were accused of, not their parental status.
That might come in a larger story -- especially a court case -- where you might report on parental status and also what they did for a living -- "The 42 year old construction company owner," the 50-year old high school teacher."






 

 
Posted by Dial Twister
May 30, 2025 12:46 pm
#9

Hope I die before I get old (talkin' 'bout my generation).
by Pete Townshend

Looks as though we didn't make it. 😉

To me, elderly is when a guy in my age range can't keep up to me in my 1.25 acre woodland garden...and I'm old.

As for adjectives as descriptors on air, newsguy1 has the correct answer.

 
Posted by RadioActive
May 30, 2025 12:49 pm
#10

I agree. When in doubt, just leave it out. You can't be wrong if you don't say anything. 

 
Posted by Mavridis
May 30, 2025 3:23 pm
#11

Damn RA!   Did you hack the CBS Standards & Practices email because they just sent out guidance on that word on Wednesday!   The word makes someone sound frail or feeble (and exactly what is the threshold for being elderly?), so we try to stay away from it.  But cops and lawyers seem to love it!    

 


 
Main page
Login
Desktop format